Going commando under a kilt is one of Scotland’s most intriguing and enduring traditions. This practice, known in Scottish kilt tailor as “going regimental,” has been a subject of fascination, humor, and cultural significance for centuries. Let’s explore the historical, practical, and cultural reasons behind this unique Scottish kilt tailor custom.
The Historical Origins of Going Commando
The tradition of wearing nothing under the kilt dates back to the original Highland dress worn by Scottish warriors in the 16th century. During this period, the Great Kilt (Féileadh Mór) was the standard garment, which consisted of a large piece of tartan fabric that could be draped and folded around the body. This versatile garment served multiple purposes:
- It provided warmth during cold Highland weather
- It offered freedom of movement during battle
- It could be used as a makeshift blanket for sleeping outdoors
- It dried quickly when wet, unlike trousers or undergarments
The practice continued with the development of the modern Leather Kilts (Féileadh Beag) in the 18th century. Scottish soldiers, particularly during the World Wars, maintained this tradition, earning it the term “going regimental.”
Practical Reasons for the Tradition
Freedom of Movement
One of the primary practical reasons for going commando under a kilt is the enhanced freedom of movement it provides. The kilt’s design allows for:
- Natural airflow and ventilation
- Unrestricted leg movement during activities
- Better comfort during long hours of wear
- Reduced fabric bunching and chafing
Climate Considerations
Scotland’s weather plays a significant role in this tradition. The wool fabric of traditional kilts:
- Keeps the wearer warm in cold conditions
- Allows for proper ventilation in warmer weather
- Dries quickly when wet
- Maintains its insulating properties even in damp conditions
Authentic Experience
Many kilt wearers believe that wearing undergarments defeats the purpose of the kilt’s traditional design and compromises its authentic nature. The natural drape and movement of the kilt fabric work best without interference from additional layers.
Cultural Significance and Modern Practice
Military Tradition
The British military, particularly Scottish regiments, has played a crucial role in maintaining this tradition. Military regulations often specified that kilts should be worn without undergarments, and this practice became a point of pride among soldiers.
Ceremonial Importance
During formal occasions and traditional Scottish ceremonies, going commando is often considered the most respectful way to wear the kilt. This includes:
- Weddings
- Highland Games
- Ceilidhs (traditional Scottish gatherings)
- Formal military events
Symbol of Scottish Identity
The practice has become deeply intertwined with Scottish cultural identity, representing:
- Cultural authenticity
- Historical connection
- National pride
- Traditional masculinity
Modern Considerations and Etiquette
When to Go Commando
While tradition favors going commando, there are times when it may be appropriate to wear undergarments:
- During particularly windy conditions
- When participating in active sports or dancing
- In formal settings where modesty is paramount
- When borrowing or renting a kilt
Proper Kilt Wearing Techniques
To maintain modesty while going commando, proper kilt-wearing technique is essential:
- Ensure the kilt is the correct length (middle of the knee)
- Properly adjust the kilt’s overlapping front apron
- Use kilt pins to secure the fabric
- Be mindful of sitting positions and movements
Common Questions and Concerns
Hygiene Considerations
Maintaining proper hygiene when going commando under a kilt involves:
- Regular cleaning and maintenance of the kilt
- Proper personal hygiene
- Understanding how to sit and move appropriately
- Being aware of weather conditions
Modern Alternatives
For those who prefer not to go completely commando, there are modern alternatives:
- Traditional kilt hose
- Modern sports underwear
- Specialized kilt undergarments
- Light compression shorts
The Future of the Tradition
While going commando under a kilt remains a strong tradition, modern attitudes and practices continue to evolve. Many contemporary kilt wearers choose to:
- Follow traditional practices for formal events
- Use modern alternatives for casual wear
- Adapt the practice to their personal comfort level
- Respect the tradition while making practical choices
Conclusion
The tradition of going commando under a kilt represents more than just a quirky cultural practice. It embodies centuries of Scottish history, practical considerations, and cultural identity. Whether choosing to embrace this tradition or opt for modern alternatives, understanding its significance helps appreciate the rich heritage of Scottish kilts and their place in both historical and contemporary culture.
Remember, while the choice of what to wear under a kilt remains a personal decision, the tradition continues to intrigue and fascinate people worldwide, adding to the mystique and charm of Scottish cultural heritage.